VIEW FROM THE SHEETS

Last updated : 15 March 2004 By Editor
Guardian:

‘Manchester United were haggard with defensive mistakes by
the 90th minute, when Shaun Wright-Phillips kept the ball in
play as it rolled along the paint of the right touchline,
moved inside and, with Wes Brown barring his path, directed
an angled chip over the head of the goalkeeper Tim Howard
and in off the crossbar.

‘When Paul Scholes reduced the deficit to 2-1 in the 35th
minute from a Ryan Giggs pass, you half-expected that Kevin
Keegan's team would be overwhelmed. The match was strewn
with opportunities then and City have no track record of
doughty resistance. They might have been in a dishevelled
state at the interval.

‘Ronaldo alone had hit the woodwork twice. He could have had
an instant equaliser to Robbie Fowler's third-minute opener
when David James blocked a Scholes attempt before flicking
the ball into his path. The Portuguese rolled his shot
against a post. Later, in the 37th minute, he almost
levelled the score when his superb, dipping drive came off
the crossbar.

‘The worst aspect for Ferguson of this failure may be that
it cannot be explained by glib reference to Rio Ferdinand's
self-imposed suspension. Missed as he is, and unwise as it
was of the manager not to purchase a seasoned replacement
such as Gareth Southgate in the transfer window, Ferguson
was let down by people he can usually trust.

‘In terms of playing time, only a few moments separated one
misjudgment by Phil Neville that led to Porto's disastrous
equaliser and the next that saw City move ahead here.
Instead of attacking Richard Dunne's long throw-in that had
been headed on by Antoine Sibierski, he awaited
developments. They took the form of the right-foot touch
from Fowler that nipped the ball away from the full-back and
the left-foot one that tucked it home in the third minute.

‘Progress was far more difficult to achieve thereafter, but
it took another mistake to polish off United. Mikaël
Silvestre's touch was crude as he attempted to control a
through-ball from Bosvelt and it slithered off his foot.
Trevor Sinclair was predatory, bustling in behind the
Frenchman to clip a shot home in the 73rd minute. United
were doomed to one of their most dispiriting experiences.’

Telegraph:

‘Eastlands reverberated to the sound of When Two Tribes Go
To War seconds before kick-off but no one imagined such
fabled warriors from across town would surrender so meekly,
their confidence as shredded as their defence. Manchester
United's season is dying of embarrassment, a team bereft of
leaders brought to their bruised knees here by the fast-
moving brilliance of Shaun Wright-Phillips.

‘Only Paul Scholes, Nicky Butt and Cristiano Ronaldo raged
against the fading of the light for United. Only this
committed trio can be exempt from the opprobrium heading the
outgoing champions' way. When United lost this fixture last
year, Sir Alex Ferguson threatened to send enraged fans into
the vanquished dressing room. This time the aggrieved Scot
should consider ushering crowing City supporters through the
door to ram home his point about the players'
underachievement.

‘Humiliated nationally by Arsenal, United are now not even
safe in their own neighbourhood and they have only
themselves to blame. Rio Ferdinand's suspension proves
costlier by the error-scarred match. Other qualities are
missing. Nerve, belief and heart are essentials in sport,
especially in such high tempo struggles as local scraps like
this. But United's usual fire was at flicker strength.

‘They moved the ball promisingly during the first half but
then folded like a deckchair in a gale. Those present etched
with most determination were their opponents, men such as
Wright-Phillips, Robbie Fowler, Daniel van Buyten and David
James, all fundamental to City's biggest derby success since
1989.

‘Arsenal will delight in this confirmation that United,
already a faint blip on the championship radar, have finally
disappeared off the screen.’

Times:

‘Humiliated by Manchester City last season, Sir Alex
Ferguson and his men used the pain to fuel their drive to
the title. Humiliated again yesterday, they are condemned to
live with the despair for the months — perhaps even the
years — that it could take them to win back the
championship.

‘This year’s race is over for Manchester United, the end
coming in another display of defensive incompetence that
their local rivals gleefully exploited to record their first
home win in the Premiership since October. The 12-point gap
to Arsenal is not only unbridgeable but could be doubled
between now and May, given the crisis of confidence that has
enveloped even class acts such as Ruud van Nistelrooy and
Ryan Giggs.

‘The uncertainty that began to afflict the defence a couple
of months ago has spread through the team like a cancer and,
rather than his usual defiance, Ferguson exudes impotence.
The United manager needs to prove that his powers are not on
the wane after a season of personal travails, but, unless
his players raise their game dramatically for the FA Cup
semi-final against Arsenal on April 4, there could be more
embarrassment before they can draw a line under this annus
horribilis.’

Independent:

‘"The temple of Doom" Sir Alex Ferguson calls the City of
Manchester Stadium, but as the final whistle sounded, the
analogy was with another Indiana Jones film. Could we be
witnessing his last crusade?

‘The first Manchester derby at Eastlands ended like the last
at Maine Road, with a comprehensive victory to Manchester
City. In November 2002, Ferguson had threatened to throw
open the dressing-room doors and have his supporters tell
the team how far they had fallen. That defeat proved a
catalyst for a remarkable fightback, but then there were six
months of the season remaining, now there are a little over
six weeks and the championship has been as good as
surrendered. Even finishing second might prove a struggle.

‘In retrospect it seems obvious that Arsenal have been the
Premiership's best team for three years now and that
Manchester United only managed to take back the championship
through a vehement act of will which this season has been
entirely absent. Ferguson has rebuilt many teams before but,
at the age of 62, you wonder whether he has the appetite to
do it again.

‘At half-time there was a feeling that Manchester United
might yet claw this game back after falling two goals
behind. They had actually been the better side before the
interval, and a strike conjured by the old firm of Ryan
Giggs and Paul Scholes put you in mind of the 1993 derby
when United had conceded two goals and somehow fashioned a 3-
2 victory. Then, however, they had been driven forward by
Roy Keane and Eric Cantona, yesterday there was nobody in a
red shirt with that all-consuming desire to win.

‘The game was settled when Mikaël Silvestre, who,
understandably given United's defensive frailties, had
probably been rushed back too soon, failed to control a
routine ball. Trevor Sinclair darted in and slid his shot
under Tim Howard. From the City dug-out, Keegan began a
manic dash down the touchline, similar to the one embarked
upon by Jose Mourinho when Porto equalised at Old Trafford.'